A Blast from the Past: Missouri Man Arrested 31 Years After Brutal Murder of Indianapolis Woman

The case of Carmen Van Huss' murder had gone cold, but 31 years later, DNA technology brought it back to life. In March 1993, Van Huss' father found her lifeless body in her Indianapolis apartment, raped and stabbed 61 times. The crime scene was replete with DNA evidence, which was submitted to a specialty company in 2018. The company's genetic genealogy analysis worked its magic, identifying 52-year-old Dana Shepherd as the prime suspect. Question: Was DNA technology the only factor that led to Shepherd's arrest, or were there other crucial pieces of evidence that helped detectives close the case? Shepherd's DNA matched the evidence found on Van Huss' body and a paper bag in her apartment. Investigators said Van Huss and Shepherd lived in the same apartment complex at the time of the murder. This proximity raises questions about potential witnesses or surveillance footage that may have been overlooked. Can you imagine how frustrating it must have been for the Van Huss family to watch as the case went cold, with no answers and no justice in sight? "For 31 years, the family of Carmen Van Huss has been searching for answers and justice," said Deputy Chief Kendale Adams. The violent nature of the crime is starkly portrayed through the devastating impact it had on Van Huss' family, particularly her father. "She was raped and stabbed over 60 times and my dad had to see her like that, blood everywhere, blood on walls, his daughter was naked, laying there … he had to see that. That changed him forever," said Van Huss' brother, Jimmy. DNA evidence was found on Van Huss' body, as well as blood on a paper bag in her apartment. In 2018, the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department submitted a sample of this DNA to a specialty company. Last year, detectives used the company's genetic genealogy analysis to identify Shepherd as a suspect. What if DNA technology hadn't advanced as quickly as it has? Would Van Huss' case have remained unsolved, leaving her family without justice? Shepherd is being held without bond at Missouri's Boone County Jail, with an extradition hearing scheduled in the coming days.