POLITICS

A Legal Battle Over Past Accusations

USATue Nov 11 2025

Donald Trump is urging the Supreme Court to intervene and overturn a $5 million decision against him. The ruling followed a jury's finding that Trump was liable for sexually abusing and defaming writer E. Jean Carroll. The incident in question occurred in 1996, but the case only went to trial in 2023.

Carroll alleged that Trump assaulted her in a department store dressing room and later denied her accusations during his presidency.

Trump's legal team contends that there is no solid evidence supporting Carroll's claims. They highlight the absence of:

  • Witnesses
  • Video footage
  • Police reports

Additionally, they argue that Carroll waited over 20 years to come forward, suggesting her motives were political and financially driven.

Uncertainty and Public Support

It remains unclear whether the Supreme Court will take up the case. Trump's legal team insists that the public supports him and wants an end to what they term "Witch Hunts." They also claim the case is politically motivated.

Roberta Kaplan, Carroll's lawyer, has not commented on recent developments. Earlier, a federal appeals court upheld the original decision, rejecting Trump's arguments. The court ruled that the judge did not err by allowing testimony from two other women who also accused Trump of sexual misconduct. Trump has denied these allegations as well.

Broader Implications

This legal battle is far from over. It raises critical questions about evidence, timing, and political motivations in high-profile cases. The outcome could significantly impact how similar cases are handled in the future.

questions

    How does the timing of E. Jean Carroll's allegations, over 20 years after the alleged incident, affect the case's validity?
    Will the Supreme Court's decision be influenced by the fact that Trump's legal team refers to the case as a 'Witch Hunt'?
    What are the potential implications of the Supreme Court's decision on future civil cases involving allegations of sexual abuse and defamation?

actions