SPORTS

Amad's Handball: A Missed Penalty That Changed the Game

Nottingham, EnglandMon Nov 03 2025

In the Premier League clash between Manchester United and Nottingham Forest, a controversial handball incident involving Amad Diallo left fans and experts questioning the referee's decision.

The Incident

  • Time: 70th minute
  • Situation: Corner kick
  • What Happened: The ball struck Amad's arm instead of his head as he attempted to clear it.
  • Referee's Decision: No penalty awarded.

Despite having a clear view, referee Darren England did not award a penalty to Nottingham Forest.

Expert Opinions

  • Keith Hackett, former PGMOL chief, criticized the decision:

    "A clear handball offence."

  • VAR's Role: No explanation provided for not intervening.

Game Impact

  • Score at the Time: Nottingham Forest leading 2-1.
  • Potential Outcome: A penalty could have secured Forest's lead.
  • Final Score: 2-2 draw.

Key Moments

  • Amad's Stunning Volley: Equalized for Manchester United.
  • Last-Minute Drama: Amad's shot cleared off the line by Forest's Murillo.

Post-Match Reactions

  • Amad's Confidence: Expressed belief in the team and manager.
  • League Standings: Manchester United remain 7th.

Upcoming Fixtures

  • Manchester United: vs. Tottenham Hotspur (next league match).
  • Nottingham Forest: vs. Sturm Graz (Europa League) and Leeds United (next league match).

Broader Implications

  • Importance of Refereeing: A single call can change the game.
  • Role of VAR: Ensuring fairness and accuracy in football.

questions

    What criteria should referees use to determine if a handball is deliberate or accidental?
    What are the implications of not awarding a penalty in situations where the ball hits a player's arm?
    How does the use of VAR affect the flow and fairness of a football match?

actions