California Puts Humans Back in Charge of Health Insurance Claims

Health insurance denials can be a nightmare for many people. Recently in California, over a quarter of health insurance claims were rejected. This is a common problem across the nation, making people angry with health care companies. Now, a new law ensures that AI can't be the sole reason for denying claims. Signed last September, this law prevents computers from solely deciding on insurance claims. Managed by Gov. Gavin Newsom, this law comes at a time when people are more frustrated with the health insurance system. In fact, a high-profile event last month involving a UnitedHealthcare executive reflected this anger. According to the California Nurses Association, about 26% of insurance claims were denied last year. This inspired Sen. Josh Becker, a Democrat from Menlo Park, to push for this law. The law, nicknamed the “Physicians Make Decisions Act, ” doesn't completely ban AI use. However, it makes sure doctors, not just machines, have the final say on coverage. In November 2023, a lawsuit against UnitedHealthcare highlighted concerns about AI misuse in healthcare decisions. This new law supports the idea that algorithms can't fully grasp a patient's unique medical needs. Sen. Becker explains that while AI has great potential, it shouldn't replace doctors' expertise. The California Department of Managed Health Care will check if denial rates are fair and ensure decisions are made within strict deadlines. Standard cases need decisions in five business days, urgent cases within 72 hours, and retrospective reviews within 30 days. The law allows regulators to fine insurance companies if they break the rules, like missing deadlines or misusing AI. Erin Mellon from the California Medical Association thinks this is crucial to protecting the doctor-patient relationship. Paula Wolfson, a manager at Avenidas Care Partners, agrees that this law brings common sense to insurance decisions. More states are now looking at similar laws, and even Congress is interested. Sen. Becker hopes this sets a national example while helping Californians.