Dam Decision: A Fresh Look at the French Broad River

The 122‑year‑old Craggy Dam has stood in Woodfin, North Carolina, for more than a century, holding back the French Broad River. Recently, local officials and conservation groups have started to question whether keeping it is still the best choice for the area. A new move by the Metropolitan Sewerage District (MSD) board on March 18 marked a clear shift. Instead of jumping straight into costly repairs, the board decided to find out how much the dam is really worth. Two separate experts will now evaluate its value, giving everyone a clear picture of what the dam costs and how much it might be worth if removed. This pause on new investments shows a careful, open approach. By waiting for solid numbers and expert opinions, the board keeps taxpayers’ money safe while exploring every possibility. It also signals that safety and community interest are top priorities.Experts say removing the dam could lower flood heights upstream, protecting homes and businesses that have faced repeated water damage. Even a small drop in flood levels can save money and keep people safe. Beyond safety, taking the dam down would let the river flow naturally again. A free‑running stretch of water can boost water quality, bring back native fish and wildlife, and open the area to new recreation and tourism opportunities. Many locals have written in to share how much they love the river and what a healthier flow would mean for them. Nationwide, towns are rethinking old dams that no longer fit their needs or pose risks. The decision in Woodfin is still early, but the board’s steps create room for a transparent conversation where all voices can be heard and every option—whether keeping or removing the dam—is weighed fairly.