ENVIRONMENT

Holly's Water Fight: Who's Right in the Dam Dispute?

Holly, MI 48442, USA,Tue Jul 29 2025

In Holly, Michigan, a heated argument is brewing between locals and the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy (EGLE). The issue? The water level of Stiff’s Mill Pond. EGLE wants it lowered, but not everyone is on board.

Resident's Frustration

Jack Stouffer, a resident who's lived near the pond for three years, is not happy. His backyard, once a pleasant sight, now smells like rotten apples. He had plans to build a seating area to enjoy the view, but the current state has changed his mind.

The Core of the Problem

The core of the problem is the dam's earth embankments. EGLE says they're unstable and pose a risk. They claim lowering the water level is a safety measure. But Stouffer isn't convinced. He thinks the danger is being exaggerated.

EGLE also points out that unauthorized changes made by the Village of Holly to the dam's embankment have made things worse. In response, the Village has taken legal action, filing an injunction to halt further drawdowns.

Questioning Priorities

Stouffer questions EGLE's priorities. He wonders why they're not more concerned about the ecosystem and wildlife. To him, it seems like the focus is solely on the dam.

A History of Disagreements

This isn't the first time Holly has faced such issues. Previous reports have highlighted similar disagreements between residents and authorities over the pond's management.

questions

    What specific evidence does EGLE have that supports the claim that the embankments near the Holly Dam are unstable?
    How have the water level changes affected the local ecosystem and wildlife, according to environmental experts?
    How do the potential risks of the dam failure compare to the impacts of lowering the water levels on the local environment?

actions