POLITICS

How Big-City Mayors Can Challenge Trump's Crime Rhetoric

USASun Aug 31 2025

Big-city mayors, mostly Democrats, are at the frontline of crime issues. They know how to talk about crime and win elections. This is a skill national Democrats need to learn.

National Democrats Struggle with Crime

National Democrats often struggle with crime. They focus on facts and data. But voters care more about how they feel. Mayors understand this. They know that even if crime rates are down, people's fears matter.

Mayors Have Real-World Experience

Mayors like Brandon Scott of Baltimore say national Democrats should listen to them. They have real-world experience in reducing crime. Congress members and national leaders don't have this.

Democrats Win on Local Issues

Democrats win mayoral races by taking crime seriously. They focus on local issues like taxes, schools, and crime. At the national level, voters often trust Republicans more on crime. But in cities, Democrats show they can handle it.

Crime is About More Than Police

Mayors also know that crime is about more than just police. It's about jobs, education, and housing. Democrats can focus on these issues. They can show they understand the root causes of crime.

Trump's Threat Could Backfire

Trump's threat to send the National Guard into cities could backfire. Most people don't want the federal government taking over local police. Mayors can play a big role in shifting the mood.

Use Mayors More

Baltimore's Scott suggests the Democratic National Committee should use mayors more. They could hold events with mayors. They could fund ads that highlight the work of mayors.

A Start, Not a Solution

This won't solve everything. But it's a start. National Democrats need to listen to mayors. They need to understand that facts alone won't win the crime debate.

questions

    What if Democratic mayors started a crime-fighting supergroup called 'The Justice League of Mayors'?
    How do Democratic mayors balance the need for emotional resonance with factual accuracy when discussing crime?
    What are the potential unintended consequences of sending the National Guard into cities?

actions