Judge’s Gift Sparks New Trial Fight
Worcester, USAWed Jun 17 2026
A Worcester judge sentenced a couple to 18 years for sex trafficking.
After the sentencing, she handed prosecutors a card and bracelet meant for the victim.
The defense says this off‑record gesture shows bias.
They want a new trial, while prosecutors only ask for a new sentencing judge.
The couple’s case began with a six‑day jury trial in September.
Prosecutors claimed the victim was abused while trafficked from February to May 2022.
During sentencing, a court staffer gave the prosecutor an envelope with a bracelet and seashells.
The card read, “Every important journey in life starts with the 1st step … I wish you much joy. ”
The prosecutor opened it after the hearing.
They kept the gifts and later told the defense in an email.
The defense filed a motion for a new trial on February 19.
Judge Guzman recused herself the next day, and a Boston judge was appointed.
Prosecutors argue the defense hasn’t met the legal standard for a new trial.
They say the judge’s comments were reasonable and that she tried to help the absent victim.
Defense lawyers claim the judge treated them unfairly, denied questions about the victim’s state, and gave the victim a gift off‑record.
They argue this undermines trust in the court’s neutrality.
Experts say the gift looked inappropriate, but it is unclear if it will lead to a new trial.
The judge’s actions raise serious questions about impartiality.
