Should Naples keep Cars on 5th? Opinions clash on traffic, charity and crowds

The annual car show on Fifth Avenue sparks heated debates every year. Some call it a beloved tradition that raises millions for local charities like St. Matthew’s House and Habitat for Humanity. Others argue it has grown out of control—clogging streets, overwhelming sidewalks and turning a once-charming event into a chaotic mess. A few residents suggest tweaking the event instead of canceling it. They recommend cutting the number of cars in half, limiting displays to one side of the street and banning live bands to focus on the vehicles. Charging a small entry fee for participants and spectators could boost charity donations while reducing crowds. Moving the show to January, a slower tourist season, might also ease traffic and parking struggles.But transparency is a major sticking point. Past events were fully charitable, with clear fundraising totals released quickly. Now, reports question where the money goes, with some speculating profits benefit private organizers rather than causes. Without full disclosure, trust erodes—even if the cars remain impressive. Location is another issue. Some propose moving the show to Horseshoe Street near the Revs Institute, where parking and space could be better managed. Others want it kept in Old Naples but scaled down to protect private property—like lawns and sprinklers—that often take a beating from visitors. The core question remains: Is this event still about community and charity, or has it become too big for its own good?