The Battle of Meniscal Tear Treatments: Repair vs. Removal

Horizontal meniscus tears (HMTs) are tricky knee injuries, but how do different treatments affect the knee's function? Let's dive into the world of biomechanics and compare meniscal repair (MR) and meniscectomy (removal of the torn part). Biomechanics, the study of how we move, shows that HMTs can change how our knee works. But how do MR and meniscectomy change things further? Well, MR tries to fix the tear, while meniscectomy cuts it out. Which one is better?Scientists haven't found much evidence to say for sure. MR might keep the knee's natural cushioning, but it could also make the tear worse if it doesn't heal right. Meniscectomy, on the other hand, gets rid of the problem part but might lead to early arthritis. It's like choosing between fixing a leaky roof or just putting a bucket under it. One might be a long-term fix, while the other is quick but could cause issues later. So, what do we do? More research is needed to understand the long-term effects of each treatment. Until then, doctors and patients need to weigh the pros and cons together.