HEALTH

Making Sense of Unclear Death Data: A Closer Look

BelgiumSun Jul 13 2025

The Importance of Clear Death Data

Death data is crucial for understanding health trends and making informed decisions. However, sometimes the reasons behind deaths are unclear, referred to as "ill-defined deaths" or "garbage codes." To address this, experts use a process called redistribution.

The Challenge in Europe

In Belgium, France, and Slovenia, a significant portion of death data remains unclear. In 2017:

  • Belgium: 34% unclear deaths
  • France: 36% unclear deaths
  • Slovenia: 20% unclear deaths

The Four-Step Redistribution Method

To improve accuracy, a four-step method was employed:

  1. Predefined codes were applied.
  2. Multiple causes of death data were used for package redistribution.
  3. Internal redistribution was conducted.
  4. Redistribution to all causes was performed.

Challenges in the Process

Despite efforts, significant hurdles remain:

  • Lack of computer power to run multiple simulations.
  • Insufficient detailed data on multiple causes of death. These issues slow down the process and reduce accuracy.

The Power of a Common Approach

A standardized method can enhance data comparison and collaboration among countries. This leads to:

  • Better health policies
  • More accurate research

The Way Forward

Experts recommend creating a standard list of unclear deaths, tailored to each country's context. This would improve data reliability and usefulness.

questions

    What are the implications of using predefined ICD codes in the redistribution process?
    Could the redistribution of ill-defined deaths be a way to divert attention from real health crises?
    What are the ethical considerations in redistributing ill-defined deaths to specific causes?

actions