Manchester United's Derby Win Sparks Debate Among Experts

Manchester United's recent 2-0 victory over Manchester City has stirred up quite the discussion among former players and analysts. The win, which came under new interim manager Michael Carrick, has left some people thrilled and others urging caution. Carrick made some notable changes for this match. He gave youngster Kobbie Mainoo his first Premier League start of the season and moved Bruno Fernandes into a more advanced role. The team also welcomed back Bryan Mbeumo and Amad Diallo from their international duties, with Mbeumo starting in a central role. The match itself was a thrilling affair, with United creating several clear chances. The home crowd was electric, reminiscent of the club's glory days under Sir Alex Ferguson. Mbeumo and Diallo were the ones who ultimately sealed the deal, scoring the goals that secured the win.However, not everyone was ready to crown Carrick a hero just yet. Roy Keane, known for his blunt honesty, cautioned against getting too carried away. He pointed out that Carrick had some favorable circumstances, like having a fully fit squad and facing a City team that wasn't at their best. Keane also reminded everyone that this was just one game and that it's too early to make any definitive judgments. On the other hand, Gary Neville was full of praise for United's performance. He believed it was a throwback to the club's best days and a sign that they could return to their former glory. Neville was particularly impressed with how Bruno Fernandes was used in the game, playing as a creative number 10 rather than in a deeper midfield role. Neville also emphasized that while this win was a great step, it's not a guarantee of future success. He hopes it can serve as a bridge to securing a European spot and potentially finishing in the top five. One thing that stood out to Neville was how Fernandes was able to impact the game when played in a more advanced role. He believes this is where Fernandes can be most effective and hopes to see him in this position more often.