Minnesota United's Controversial Win: A Look at the Ref's Missed Call

In a recent MLS Cup Playoffs game, Minnesota United (MNUFC) secured a narrow 3-2 victory over Seattle Sounders through a penalty shootout. However, the match was overshadowed by a controversial no-call in the ninth minute.

The Controversial No-Call

Bongi Hlongwane, a forward for the Loons, was pushed by Seattle's Jackson Ragen while on a breakaway. The contact caused Hlongwane to miss his shot, and the referee, Alexis Da Silva, did not call a foul.

Coach's Reaction

Head coach Eric Ramsay was vocal about the missed call, stating it was one of the clearest penalties he'd seen all year. He expressed disappointment, emphasizing the importance of trust in referees, especially with the assistance of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology.

"It was one of the clearest penalties I've seen all year. I'm disappointed, but we have to trust the referees and the VAR."

Ramsay's criticism is rare, as he usually reviews footage before commenting on officiating.

Impact on the Game

The no-call had a significant impact on the game, which ended scoreless after 90 minutes. Ramsay admitted he was relieved to win, as the outcome could have been much different without the penalty. He might face a fine from MLS for his public criticism.

Referee's Response

The Professional Referee Organization (PRO) responded to inquiries, stating that the contact did not warrant a foul or a red card. They also mentioned that VAR did not see a clear error in the on-field decision.

Player Reactions

Goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair received a yellow card for dissent, arguing for consistency in foul calls. He pointed out that pushing a player in the back without attempting to play the ball should result in a red card.

"It's about consistency. If you push a player in the back without attempting to play the ball, it should be a red card."

Throughout the match, Minnesota players were issued five yellow cards, while Seattle had none. Seattle committed more fouls (16) than Minnesota (11).

Broader Implications

This incident raises questions about the consistency and accuracy of refereeing in soccer, especially with the help of VAR. It also highlights the impact of such decisions on the outcome of games.