OPINION
New York's Car-Free Future: A Tale of Road Charges
New York, Manhattan, USASun Jan 05 2025
Do you remember the French Revolution and the angry mob tearing down toll booths? Believe it or not, something similar is happening in New York City today. Governor Kathy Hochul is about to start a new program called congestion pricing. This isn't about sticking it to the king, though. It's about making the city cleaner and less crowded.
New York's plan is to charge drivers who want to enter Manhattan's busy areas during the day. The idea is to reduce traffic and air pollution, and use the money to improve buses and trains. Governor Hochul wasn't sure about this at first, but she's given it a go, setting the fee at $9. That's a bit less than the original plan of $15.
This isn't just a New York thing. Democrats across the country are watching to see if this works. If it does, it could show that they can make big changes, even when times are tough. Lots of people in the city's boroughs and suburbs didn't vote for Democrats in the last election. So, this is a chance to win them back.
People who support the plan think most New Yorkers will like it because it helps with traffic and public transport. They also think it will get more popular over time, just like in other cities that have tried it.
But is it really that simple? Will people change their minds if they have to pay to drive into the city? And can Democrats really make tough decisions and see them through? These are the big questions as New York's experiment begins.
continue reading...
questions
Do you think the initial high fee of $15 was a deliberate tactic to make the lowered fee of $9 seem more acceptable?
If New Yorkers could vote on congestion pricing with a glass of now-untaxed wine, do you think the outcome would be different?
What empirical data supports the assumption that a silent majority of car-free households in New York City supports congestion pricing?
actions
flag content