OPINION
New York's New Crime Fighting Tool: The Panic Button
New York, USATue May 06 2025
New York City has a new strategy for dealing with crime. It is not about stopping it before it happens. Instead, it is about reacting to it after it starts. This is the Panic Button Doctrine. The city plans to spend $1. 6 million to install these buttons in 500 bodegas. Each button costs $3, 200. This plan is more about looking like they are doing something than actually preventing crime.
The idea is simple. If a crime happens, someone presses the button. It connects directly to the NYPD's command center. This skips the usual 911 call process. The mayor, Eric Adams, thinks this will surprise criminals. He believes they won't know which stores have the buttons. This is like trying to scare off a burglar by hiding a security system.
But will it work? Critics say it won't. They point out that crime prevention is about more than just reacting. It's about stopping crime before it starts. The Panic Button Doctrine does not do this. It is a reactive measure. It is like waiting for a fire to start before calling the fire department.
The city's plan has sparked some creative ideas. Some people joke about other panic buttons. For example, a button for women to ward off unwanted advances. Or a button for subway safety. Or a button for mental health crises. These ideas show the absurdity of the Panic Button Doctrine. They highlight the need for real solutions, not just gimmicks.
The truth is, New York City has big problems. It needs real solutions. Not just buttons. The city's leaders need to do the hard work. They need to come up with creative solutions. Not just rely on tech gimmicks. New Yorkers deserve better than this. They deserve leaders who are serious about public safety.
continue reading...
questions
How effective are panic buttons in preventing crime compared to proactive policing strategies?
What if criminals start carrying their own panic buttons to call for backup during heists?
How does the cost of installing panic buttons compare to other crime prevention measures?
inspired by
actions
flag content