Oscar-Winning Filmmaker Attacked by Settlers in West Bank

West BankTue Mar 25 2025
The West Bank has seen another violent clash. This time, it involved a well-known filmmaker. Hamdan Ballal, a Palestinian co-director of the Oscar-winning documentary "No Other Land, " was attacked by Israeli settlers. This incident happened in the village of Susiya. Shortly after, the Israeli military detained him. The attack happened just after the filmmakers returned from the Oscars. It seems like a harsh welcome back. Basel Adra, another co-director, saw the whole thing. He reported that around two dozen settlers, some armed and masked, stormed the village. Soldiers arrived and pointed their guns at the Palestinians, while settlers threw stones. The Israeli military has a different story. They claim they detained three Palestinians for throwing rocks. They also mentioned a "violent confrontation" between Israelis and Palestinians. Witnesses dispute this account. The military also said they transferred the detainees to Israeli police for questioning. "No Other Land" is a powerful film. It shows the struggle of residents in the Masafer Yatta area. They are fighting to stop the Israeli military from demolishing their villages. The film has won many awards and faced criticism. It has sparked debates in Israel and abroad. The attack on Ballal happened after residents broke their fast for Ramadan. A settler, known for frequent attacks, went to Ballal's home with the military. Soldiers fired shots in the air. Ballal's wife heard him being beaten and screaming. She heard him say, "I'm dying. " Adra saw soldiers lead Ballal, handcuffed and blindfolded, into a military vehicle. Ballal's blood was still on the ground outside his home. Another eyewitness confirmed some of Adra's account. They spoke anonymously out of fear. A group of masked settlers also assaulted activists with the Center for Jewish Nonviolence. They smashed car windows and slashed tires to make them leave. The West Bank has a complex history. Israel captured it in the 1967 Mideast war. Palestinians want it for their future state. Israel has built over 100 settlements there. The 3 million Palestinians in the West Bank live under Israeli military rule. The Palestinian Authority administers population centers. Masafer Yatta is a hotspot. Israel designated it as a live-fire training zone in the 1980s. They ordered residents to leave. Around 1, 000 residents have stayed. Soldiers regularly demolish homes, tents, and orchards. Palestinians fear expulsion. The situation is tense. Israel has killed hundreds of Palestinians in the West Bank. There has been a rise in settler attacks on Palestinians. There has also been a surge in Palestinian attacks on Israelis. The future of the West Bank remains uncertain.
https://localnews.ai/article/oscar-winning-filmmaker-attacked-by-settlers-in-west-bank-a960745

questions

    What if the settlers were actually just really bad at giving standing ovations?
    If the settlers were trying to punish the filmmakers, why didn't they just send them a strongly worded letter?
    How does the Israeli military's narrative of the events differ from the accounts provided by witnesses and the filmmakers?

actions