School Plan Sparks Debate: One Elementary School to Close

Southington’s school board has set a new course for the town’s education system, choosing to close one elementary school as part of a larger construction project. The decision came after a detailed presentation at the board’s February meeting, where experts outlined options for building updates and cost estimates. The plan focuses on shrinking the number of schools to match falling student numbers, with the smallest and least viable building—Flanders Elementary—being earmarked for closure. The chosen path, called Scenario D, would see a referendum in June 2026 to fund a new Kelley Elementary and expand South End. After that, Flanders would shut down, and the remaining schools would be reorganized.The projected costs are hefty: about $43. 9 million for the new Kelley and South End expansion, and roughly $60. 5 million for a brand‑new Derynoski Elementary plus the Karen Smith Academy’s move. The total district share tops out at $104. 3 million, with hopes of state reimbursements and grants to help offset the expense. The board’s motion passed 8‑1, reflecting a mix of fiscal caution and reluctance to close a community hub. Community reactions split sharply. Some parents and residents fear that closing Flanders will hurt stability, increase class sizes, and erase local history. Others argue that a new, modern building will offer safer, more efficient learning environments and that the town must adapt to changing demographics. The board emphasized transparency, noting public hearings and a willingness to revisit the plan if circumstances shift. The referendum’s outcome will decide whether Southington moves forward with this ambitious consolidation. Until then, the town remains divided over how best to balance financial realities with community values.