Senate Democrats: To Shut Down or Not to Shut Down?

Senate Democrats are in a tough spot. They have to decide whether to help Republicans pass a funding bill or block it and risk a government shutdown. This decision comes as the deadline for a shutdown looms. The House has already approved a bill to fund agencies through September. This bill was passed mostly along party lines, and Senate Democrats have been debating their next move. Their base wants them to fight against the rapid cuts to the federal workforce. However, some Democrats are worried about the unpredictable impact and length of a shutdown. They also have to consider the political impact, as Republicans control the House, Senate, and White House. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has said that Republicans don't have the votes to pass the bill without Democratic support. Senate Republicans need eight Democratic votes to overcome a filibuster. However, Kentucky GOP Sen. Rand Paul has said he will vote no on the plan unless it codifies cuts led by Elon Musk. Only one Senate Democrat, John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, has said he will vote with the GOP to approve the CR. Fetterman wants to avoid a shutdown, calling it "chaos. " Schumer has proposed a four-week stopgap measure. This would keep agencies funded at current levels through April 11 as both parties negotiate on the annual spending bills. This alternative gives Democrats the chance to say they are working to avoid any lapse in government funding. Senate Majority Leader John Thune has said he is open to giving Democrats an opportunity to vote on their proposal, but he doesn't expect it to pass. In the hours that followed Schumer's push for the short-term bill, two Senate Democrats up for re-election in 2026, Sens. Mark Warner and John Hickenlooper, said they would vote no on the GOP-backed measure. However, Fetterman argued Schumer's plan doesn't have a chance. He said, "Shut the government down, plunge the country into chaos, risk a recession or Exchange cloture for a 30 day CR that 100% fails. " He believes the House GOP CR will then pass the Senate because it only needs 51 votes. Several Senate Democrats have yet to say how they'd like to vote on the plan. Many Democrats described the choice facing them as a "pick your poison" moment with no easy answer. Helping Republicans pass the CR avoids a shutdown and issues they argue impact defense and other programs that are relying on increases instead of flat funding. But blocking it opens them up to the uncertainty of what the Trump administration would decide about who qualifies as essential workers and what other cuts they could impose during a shutdown. Sen. Mark Kelly told reporters he was "weighing the badness of each option. " This, as several Senate Democrats said early on they would vote no on the plan. That includes Sen. Elizabeth Warren. She told reporters, "I don't know how anybody can vote for this. " House Democrats remained largely united on opposing the plan, and many took to social media to urge their Senate Democratic counterparts to do the same.