FINANCE

Smart Ways to Invest Using Direct Indexing

USASat Nov 01 2025

Direct indexing is revolutionizing the way people invest. It's no longer just for the ultra-wealthy. This strategy allows investors to cherry-pick stocks from an index, such as the S&P 500, rather than buying a fund that tracks the entire index. While it may seem straightforward, it's a significant shift. Investors can tailor their portfolios to align with their principles and optimize tax efficiency.

Customization and Control

One of the standout benefits of direct indexing is the ability to invest in accordance with personal values. Want to steer clear of tobacco or weapons? No issue. Prefer to allocate more funds to renewable energy or AI? You can do that too. This level of customization is unavailable with traditional index funds.

Direct indexing also empowers investors with greater control over their portfolios. They can fine-tune their holdings, avoid redundancies, and even gift individual stocks. Thanks to advancements in technology, everyday investors can now access capabilities that were once exclusive to large institutions.

Tax Loss Harvesting

Another major advantage is tax loss harvesting. If a stock in your portfolio declines in value, you can sell it to offset gains elsewhere. This can substantially impact your after-tax returns. Unlike mutual funds or ETFs, direct indexing enables tax management at the individual stock level.

Accessibility and Cost

Direct indexing is particularly beneficial for high-income investors aiming to minimize taxes. It's also ideal for those who prioritize ethical investing and wish to personalize their portfolios. Previously, direct indexing was reserved for the affluent, but fintech platforms have made it accessible to all. Some platforms allow you to start with as little as $1,000, with fees ranging from 0.20% to 0.40%.

Choosing a Platform

When selecting a direct indexing platform, consider the following:

  • Tax Loss Harvesting Frequency: How often do they harvest tax losses?
  • Customization Options: What personalization choices are available?
  • Fees: Are the fees clear and transparent?
  • Reporting and Support: Is the reporting comprehensive and the support reliable?

For beginners, platforms like Public.com are a good starting point. If you have a larger account balance, you might prefer options like Charles Schwab.

Getting Started

To begin with direct indexing:

  1. Determine Your Investment Amount: Decide how much of your taxable assets you want to invest this way.
  2. Compare Platforms: Evaluate platforms based on fees, tools, customization options, and minimum investment requirements.
  3. Set Your Preferences: Establish your customization preferences.
  4. Monitor and Rebalance: Regularly monitor and rebalance your portfolio.

Conclusion

Direct indexing is making investing more personalized and tax-efficient. It's no longer exclusive to the wealthy. Platforms like Public.com, Fidelity, and Schwab have made it easier than ever to build a portfolio that aligns with your goals and values. If you're looking to reduce taxes, gain more control, or make your portfolio more personal, direct indexing could be a smart choice.

questions

    Can direct indexing truly offer better tax efficiency for all investors, or are there specific conditions where it excels?
    If you use direct indexing to exclude all stocks that don't align with your values, will your portfolio end up being just a single stock?
    How does direct indexing compare to traditional index funds in terms of long-term performance?

actions