POLITICS

The Fight Over Birthright Citizenship: What's at Stake?

USAThu May 15 2025
The Supreme Court is in the spotlight again, this time tackling a big question: Can the president end birthright citizenship with just a signature? This isn't just about one order, it's about the power struggle between the president and the courts. The 14th Amendment is clear: anyone born in the US is a citizen. But the Trump administration thinks there's a loophole. They argue that "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" means some kids born here don't count. Legal experts aren't buying it. They say the Constitution is clear, and the president can't just change it with an order. This isn't the first time courts have blocked Trump's orders. They've stopped him before, and now he's fighting back. He wants the Supreme Court to say that lower courts can't block his orders nationwide. If he wins, he could keep using executive orders to get his way, with less pushback from the courts. The case is unusual. It's May, and the Supreme Court doesn't often hear arguments this time of year. Plus, three of the justices are Trump's picks, so it's anyone's guess how they'll rule. The fight is about more than just citizenship. It's about who gets to decide what the law means. If the Supreme Court sides with Trump, it could change how the president and the courts work together. It could also affect tens of thousands of kids born in the US to undocumented parents. Some could end up undocumented or even stateless, with no country to call home. The case is a mix of three lawsuits, from both immigration advocates and states. They're all asking the same question: Who gets to decide who's a citizen? The answer could change the lives of many people in the US. The fight over birthright citizenship is just one example of the power struggle between the president and the courts. It's a battle that's been going on for years, and it's not over yet. The Supreme Court's decision could tip the balance, one way or the other.

questions

    How does the Trump administration's argument on 'jurisdiction thereof' hold up under a thorough legal analysis?
    Will the children of undocumented immigrants need to start carrying around birth certificates with a 'Made in China' label to prove they were born in the US?
    Are the frequent court injunctions against Trump's orders a sign of a deeper conspiracy within the judicial system?

actions