POLITICS

Troops on the Streets: A Power Struggle

USATue Oct 07 2025

President Donald Trump's recent moves to deploy the National Guard against local leaders' wishes have ignited a significant legal conflict. This dispute isn't just about the deployment of troops; it's about the balance of power between the federal government and the states.

Trump's Justification vs. Critics' Concerns

  • Trump's Perspective: Views the deployments as a means to combat crime and immigration.
  • Critics' Perspective: See it as a power grab, particularly with the unprecedented use of the National Guard to patrol cities.
  • Posse Comitatus Act: A nearly 150-year-old law that restricts the military's role in domestic law enforcement.
  • Insurrection Act: Allows the president to deploy active-duty military in states unable to control unrest or defying federal law.

Legal experts are scrutinizing whether Trump's orders align with the Constitution and relevant laws governing the National Guard's use.

States Fighting Back

  • Illinois, Oregon, and California: Have filed lawsuits against Trump's actions, all led by Democratic governors.
  • Governors' Responses: Gavin Newsom (California) and JB Pritzker (Illinois) have had to announce troop deployments despite their opposition.

Concerns Over Presidential Powers

  • Elizabeth Goitein, an expert on presidential powers, warns that Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth may see these deployments as practice for overseas conflicts.
  • Court Interventions: Trump's opponents have used the court system to delay his plans, raising concerns about potential non-compliance with court orders.

Pentagon's Struggles

Pentagon officials are struggling to provide basic details about these operations, highlighting the unprecedented nature of the situation.

Historical Context

This situation contrasts sharply with President John F. Kennedy's 1963 move to federalize the Alabama National Guard to enforce civil rights laws.

continue reading...

questions

    If the National Guard is deployed to American cities for training, will they offer discounts at local coffee shops for soldiers in uniform?
    What are the long-term consequences of expanding the role of the military in domestic affairs on the democratic principles of the United States?
    What are the potential risks and benefits of federalizing the National Guard in response to local crises?

actions

flag content