POLITICS

What Does Peace Really Mean?

Anchorage, Alaska, USAMon Aug 18 2025

Key Points

  • No Agreement Reached: The meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska did not result in a deal.
  • Original Goal: The meeting was planned to discuss a ceasefire in Ukraine but was later described as a "listening exercise."
  • Expert Skepticism: Experts were doubtful about any real progress, with some noting it was a "big win" for Putin.

Details

Meeting Overview

The meeting, initially aimed at discussing a ceasefire in Ukraine, was later framed as a "listening exercise" by White House Spokesperson Karoline Leavitt. The goal was to help Trump understand how to potentially end the war.

Expert Reactions

  • Tina Fordham, founder of Fordham Global Foresight, stated that Putin did not take Trump seriously.
  • Richard Portes, head of the economics faculty at the London Business School, noted that the meeting itself was a "big win" for Putin, as it was his first visit to U.S. soil in about a decade.

Trump's Perspective

Despite no agreement being reached, Trump called the meeting "very productive." The next day, he announced he would pursue a "peace agreement" instead of a ceasefire.

Different Visions of Peace

  • For Ukraine: An end to the war and the withdrawal of foreign troops.
  • For Russia: Gaining new territory.
  • For Some: Winning a Nobel Peace Prize, no matter the cost.

Complex Nature of Peace Talks

The meeting highlighted the complex nature of peace talks, showing how different parties have different ideas about what peace looks like. This makes finding a common ground very difficult.

Current Situation

The situation in Ukraine remains tense. The meeting did not bring any immediate relief. It is clear that the road to peace is long and complicated, with different visions of peace among the involved parties making it even harder to achieve.

questions

    What historical precedents can be drawn upon to guide the current peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine?
    Could the reframing of the summit as a 'listening exercise' be a cover for secret negotiations or deals?
    How can international mediators facilitate a dialogue that addresses the differing definitions of peace held by Ukraine, Russia, and the United States?

actions