The Faithful and the Welcoming: Unpacking the Heart of Midwestern Lutheranism

In the heart of America's Midwest, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) has been a beacon of warmth, inclusivity, and community for generations. When Governor Tim Walz, a Lutheran raised Catholic, brought his progressive legislative record onto the Democratic ticket, the nation took notice of the church's unwavering commitment to social justice and equality. But what makes Midwestern Lutheranism so unique? It's not just the warm cookies and lutefisk served at potlucks – it's the unwavering sense of belonging and the willingness to welcome all, regardless of their political views. In the vibrant city of Minneapolis, the Iglesia Luterana San Pablo – a predominantly Latino congregation – is a shining example of this inclusive spirit. Founded by Swedish immigrants in the late 19th century, the church has grown to become a true melting pot, with services in both English and Spanish. A pride flag proudly hangs in the sanctuary, a testament to the church's welcoming nature. "Faith is love," says Lizete Vega, a council president at San Pablo. "It's loving everyone as we are. " Across the state, in the charming hamlet of Kenyon, the Holden Lutheran Church is another embodiment of this warm and fuzzy Midwestern Lutheranism. With a rich history dating back to 1857, Holden has been a staple of the community, serving as a hub for social events and outreach programs. When asked about the church's role in politics, Jeff Davidson, a sixth-generation farmer and member of the congregation, simply says, "You don't come to coffee after church and start a political conversation or other hotbed issues, you know? I think we all need to just push some of that back and leave it back there. " This unwavering commitment to inclusivity is not limited to San Pablo or Holden; it's a characteristic shared by many Lutheran congregations across the Midwest. The Rev. Elise Pokel, pastor at Transfiguration Lutheran Church in suburban Bloomington, notes that "people are listening for their side of things" and that "it's like, well, I pledge my allegiance to Jesus. " The Rev. Dustin Haider, who serves both Holden and another congregation, emphasizes that "where in our social do we need justice? " is the correct approach to outreach. But what's behind this unique blend of warmth and inclusivity? For some, it's the result of Luther's "freedom and service" theology, which emphasizes serving others. For others, it's the influence of Scandinavian and German settlers who brought their own cultural traditions and values to the region. Whatever the reason, this Midwestern brand of Lutheranism is a refreshing respite from the partisanship and polarization that often dominates our national discourse.