POLITICS

The Future of Scientific Publishing is at Stake

USAFri May 30 2025
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. caused a stir recently. He is the head of the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services. He suggested that government scientists might stop publishing their research in top medical journals. He made this statement on a podcast called "The Ultimate Human". The journals he mentioned are The Lancet, the New England Journal of Medicine, and JAMA. These are some of the most respected and widely read medical journals in the world. They publish studies that have been reviewed by other experts in the field. This process is known as peer review. Kennedy's reasoning? He believes these journals are corrupt. He thinks they are controlled by drug companies. He wants the government to create its own journals instead. He believes these new journals would be the most trusted because they would be backed by the National Institutes of Health (NIH). This idea has sparked a lot of debate. Some public health experts are not on board with Kennedy's plan. Dr. Adam Gaffney, a professor at Harvard Medical School, thinks it's a bad idea. He believes it would make government-funded research less credible. He also worries that it could harm public health. Kennedy has been vocal about his views on the pharmaceutical industry. He has criticized several government agencies under HHS. He thinks they are too influenced by drug companies. This includes the CDC, FDA, NIH, and the offices that handle Medicare and Medicaid. Kennedy's department has also made some controversial moves lately. They stopped recommending the COVID-19 vaccine for healthy children and pregnant women. This goes against the CDC's guidance. They also released a report that challenges common views in medicine. Some of the information in the report is not backed by strong evidence. The department has also seen some big changes. There have been major staff cuts, with about 20, 000 federal workers let go. This has affected almost every part of the agency. Because of these cuts and funding freezes, some U. S. scientists are thinking about leaving the country for better job opportunities. Countries like France, Germany, Spain, and China are actively recruiting American researchers.

questions

    How does Kennedy plan to ensure that the new HHS journals maintain the same level of scientific rigor and peer review as established journals like The Lancet and NEJM?
    Are there any hidden agendas behind the sudden reduction in NIH funding and the push for new HHS journals?
    What are the potential long-term impacts on public health if government-funded research is siloed within HHS journals?

actions