EDUCATION
Can Listening Alone Change Your Mind?
USAFri Feb 21 2025
Immigration is a hot topic with lots of different opinions. A recent experiment looked into whether listening to others can change their minds. 1, 400 people in the U. S. had video chats with trained canvassers. The canvassers either shared a story about an undocumented immigrant, listened carefully to the participants, or did both.
The results showed that telling a persuasive story did change people's minds about immigration policies and reduced prejudice. This change lasted for weeks. But just listening carefully didn't make the story more persuasive. People's minds were changed by the story, not by the listening.
So, what does this mean? Listening might not be the magic solution to changing minds. It's important to share a good story or argument. Listening is great for making people like you more and think about what you're saying. But it might not be enough to change their minds on its own.
This study is a reminder that persuasion is complex. It's not just about listening. It's about what you say and how you say it. So, next time you're trying to convince someone, remember: a good story goes a long way.
The experiment focused on immigration, but the findings can apply to many other topics. It's important to think critically about how we communicate and persuade others. Listening is valuable, but it's not the only tool in the persuasion toolbox. A good story or argument is often more effective in changing minds.
It's also worth noting that the study was conducted in the U. S. , where immigration is a highly debated topic. The results might be different in other countries or cultures. But the general idea that listening alone might not be enough to change minds is still relevant.
So, next time you're trying to convince someone, think about what you're saying and how you're saying it. A good story can make a big difference. But don't forget to listen too. It's important to understand the other person's perspective.
continue reading...
questions
What if the canvassers had listened to the participants' opinions about their favorite TV shows instead of unauthorized immigration?
What alternative explanations could account for the lack of enhanced persuasion from high-quality listening?
Were the canvassers' true intentions to persuade or to gather information for a larger agenda?
inspired by
actions
flag content